Guest Writer – James Jones
03.20.06 – The NFL off season is without a doubt the longest 8 months of my life… every, single, year. Needless to say, being as close as I am to the San Francisco 49ers makes that 8 months every year seem even longer than it really is. I have ventured on many attempts to conclude why this is the case however there seems to be no clear cut answer. Than I begin to speculate as to how a football, a game that is played by kids worldwide, could be such an enormous aspect of my life. How does one quantify the importance of football or any sport for that matter. The point is that there are many things in life that mean more to some then others.
Ask my wife what football means to her and she might tell you that it is the one facet of our life that consumes as much time as she does. Needless to say she would be right, although it is this time of year when it all hit’s a distinct lull. One that I know everyone here despises and simply wishes would go by faster then time will allow. Either way we are in this for the long haul, so buckle up and get ready for a long (and hopefully) eventful ride.
First let’s look at where we stand now. Several players have been lost since the end of last season, whether it was through free agency or the team simply letting them go, the 49ers will look a bit different this September when they take the field to kickoff the 2006 season. While the team has been relatively quiet (according to some) on the free agent front thus far, they have made some signings and are looking to reinforce the roster with others as the weeks come. While career backups such as Bryan Gilmore and Jason McAddley are with the team, there has been a serious uproar in certain circles at the lack of big name talent being pursued by the team. Even while there has been talk of free agent linebacker Julian Peterson being retained as well as other potential signings, nothing has come to fruition, save for WR Antonio Bryant being inked two weeks ago. Regardless of what the 49ers have or have not done since the Collective Bargaining Agreement was renewed and free agency finally began the fact remains that they need to do something more before training camp begins this July.
Resigning Julian Peterson: This could go either way and Mike Nolan has stated time and time again that no player will be bigger then the team. I believe this to be a quality philosophy, but one has to ask when does the team take a step to retain it’s most prized free agent, the same one it saw fit to make it’s franchise player the last two seasons? Whatever your take on Julian Peterson, to a man he helps this team on defense and should be retained; although this is looking increasingly doubtful as time goes on.
Peter Boulware: Alright this is another move that while would be good news for the locker room and defense in general most likely won’t take place. The former Raven has insinuated that he might retire and take a position with the Baltimore coaching ranks. Barring something special I don’t really see this happening.
Trade rumors: We have been hearing much buzz of trades that might take place, based on what other teams are trying to do. Barlow to Denver, Philadelphia is reportedly shopping DB Brian Dawkins for a combination of picks and a player, another has Denver looking to unload their two first round picks in this years draft for a high selection in the 2007 draft. While there is no credence to these stories as of yet, at least not where the 49ers are concerned, any of these could serve to assist the team in the coming season.
The off season is far from over, as I mentioned about, and while I expect the team to make more moves I do not expect an overwhelming amount of activity. This is based no doubt on Paraag Marathes “Billy Bean, Moneyball” strategy, which by the way has no place within the realm of the National Football League, makes it almost a certainty. Allow me to elaborate on this if you will, see baseball is a completely different sport then football. I know what you are saying now, “No kidding Jones, now get the hell outta here” But let me explain. See the reason that moneyball works in baseball is because, simply put it can. A team fields nine players per game, over any given nine innings, a sub par left fielder might go through a game and only see a ball hit to him twice a game. The ball is in the air, the player gets under it, the player makes the catch. Ok well what about offense right? Well even if a guy can’t hit the ball for average or power, there is at least one other man on the team who can and will. Also there are 164 games in a single baseball season, football has but 16 this fact alone should make it apparent that this philosophy wont work. Looking a little deeper you can see… putting a sub par linebacker on the outside of a 3-4 defense and chances are your defense is going to be torched on that side of the ball all game long.
I am well aware of teams such as New England and Philadelphia taking the approach of not going crazy in free agency and letting players who demand higher salaries leave to other teams, however the glaring difference is that the 49ers have no one in the mold of a Tom Brady or Donovan McNabb. This team was so devoid of talent last season that it is going to be required to find some… anywhere.
I was listening to The Opening Drive on the Sirius NFL station the other day and Randy Cross said that if the 49ers resign Peterson that he feels it would be their last free agent signing as it would cost as much as people are predicting. Then he went on to say that he does not see them doing it anyway based on the fact that in their eyes paying as much does not match up to the statistics he has put up recently. It is a well known fact that Julian has not been playing on a Pro Bowl level as of late, but there are other things that cannot be measured by stats alone. Locker room presence and leadership are a few of them. One thing that I can say beyond the shadow of a doubt is that if he is on this team come July, look for him to take an increased role of leading this defense and taking his game where he needs to. If he is not on the team in July then look for him to do the very same, just watch him do it for someone else. One more thing remember what you read here, no matter where Peterson plays this season he will return to All-Pro form and it is my sincere hope that he does it in Red and Gold





gold digger said:
I wish there were more discussions about the “billy bean moneyball” philosophy. In my opinion, Paraag Marathes should have nothing to do with football. This man has zero NFL or football knowledge. I agree with all that you wrote, but could you offer up a suggestion that has to do with the 49er front office and not just the players we need to retain or get? I would be interested in that more than what big name we chould get out there.
13 mins after the fact.James said:
Well I think you hit the nail on the head right there my man… getting rid of the philosohpy and namely Marathe. He has place on this team let alone this league. We need a real football guy in there and someone who actually cares about not only the game but about this team winning period.
1 hour after the fact.gold digger said:
How about this: When the beloved Eddie D. left, he took all the love for this organization with him. And i am not just talking about love for the San Francisco 49ers. I am talking about love for the game as well. With the exception of Nolan and McCloughan, this front office might as well read like the front office and Cisco or IBM.
1 hour after the fact.Jerald said:
James baseball has 162 games a year.
4 hours after the fact.Dave said:
While I agree that the jury is definitely out on Marathe and the early indications aren’t looking great, I don’t think you make a very solid argument against the “Moneyball” philosophy. Whether it really works or not, nothing you said makes a strong case either way.
Following the philosophy of teams that build smart rosters, focus on depth, players who play with heart and motivation, and team dynamics is a good idea. Not blowing your whole cap on a few big name players whose questionable character or sketchy past performance could kill your team is a good idea. Signing young, promising players to inexpensive long term deals is a good idea. Leaving the door open to new, innovative ideas for player evaluation is a good idea. These are all good ideas, and eventually they will lead us in the right direction.
Oh and why are you so convinced that Peterson will return to Pro Bowl form this year? Why do you so boldly declare that he will all of the sudden become a clubhouse leader? I don’t refute either, but neither of us can declare out right that those predictions will come true. I understand that this is a fansite, and that some bias is unavoidable, but some of the blind fanatacism I see here is far too over the top. I for one would like to see some more balanced, measured writing and reporting on this site.
5 hours after the fact.Jorge said:
Well said Dave.
5 hours after the fact.Andrew said:
Well, he is a Guest writer.
6 hours after the fact.James said:
Yeah lick balls Andrew ever hear of a typo?
7 hours after the fact.Andrew said:
Do what? Sorry for defending you.
15 hours after the fact.James said:
Kidding man… have you been in the forums?
18 hours after the fact.Andrew said:
I have not. Just discovered this site recently.
23 hours after the fact.Darrel said:
James brought some quality opinion to the table, if u r gonna knock it, then lay down a case dont just bash the dude. Its easy to sit back and take shots but most of his stuff seems valid to this niner fan. Peterson is gonna be kicking our ass for the next 3 years, thats BS!! My favorite portion of that post was that maybe the Eagles r looking to part with Dawk, which we have all heard recently. We need some leaders for after BY’s retirement, or how about just one??!! JP going 2 SEA hurts me deep, very deep. Lets bring back Walsh 4 our front office job that nobody wants.
1 day after the fact.Anonymous said:
Geiger salters:cathedrals!exalting pipers Hobday
46 days after the fact.Anonymous said:
distinction?Ciceronianizes?forms Winters imprisonment threshold?
47 days after the fact.Anonymous said:
organism merchandise petition blazed abyss:... Thanks
47 days after the fact.